top of page
< Back

Kirkup report (Morecombe)

The Kirkup Report was an independent investigation into the management, delivery, and outcomes of maternity and neonatal services at the University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust, identifying significant failures and making recommendations to prevent future incidents

The **Kirkup Report**, formally known as the **Report of the Morecambe Bay Investigation**, was an independent inquiry chaired by **Dr. Bill Kirkup CBE**. It investigated serious failings in maternity and neonatal services at the **University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust** between **January 2004 and June 2013**. The inquiry was initiated in response to a series of tragic incidents, including the deaths of three mothers and 16 babies, which highlighted significant deficiencies in the care provided.


The investigation, which lasted approximately **14 months** and culminated in the publication of the final report in **March 2015**, uncovered a range of systemic issues and failures within the Trust. The inquiry found that the maternity unit at the Furness General Hospital was characterized by dysfunctional working relationships, a lack of effective leadership, and poor clinical practice. Midwives, doctors, and other healthcare professionals failed to work together as a cohesive team, leading to substandard care and preventable harm.


One of the key findings was the existence of a culture of denial, collusion, and cover-up within the Trust. The inquiry revealed that staff were reluctant to report or acknowledge mistakes, and there was a general lack of accountability. This culture significantly contributed to the persistence of poor practices and the inability to learn from adverse events. The report also highlighted the inadequacies of the regulatory and supervisory bodies, which failed to identify and address the issues at Morecambe Bay in a timely and effective manner.


As a result of its findings, the Kirkup Report made **44 recommendations** aimed at improving the safety and quality of maternity and neonatal services. These recommendations were divided into two categories: **18 specific to the Trust** and **26 for the wider NHS**. Key recommendations included the need for better training and supervision of midwives and medical staff, improved teamwork and communication, and the establishment of robust systems for reporting and learning from incidents. The report also called for stronger regulatory oversight and greater transparency to ensure that patient safety is prioritized.


The impact of the Kirkup Report was significant, leading to changes in policies and practices within the NHS to enhance the safety and quality of maternity care. The findings and recommendations underscored the importance of a culture of openness, learning, and accountability in healthcare settings to prevent similar tragedies in the future.


In one sentence: The Kirkup Report investigated significant failings in maternity and neonatal services at the University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust, resulting in 44 recommendations to improve patient safety and care.


Key numbers at a glance

44

Recommendations

14

Months to complete

Cost in millions      (if known)

19

Deaths (direct)

Recommendations

Recommendation

Description

Trust-Specific Recommendations

18 specific recommendations aimed at improving practices within the University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust

Wider NHS Recommendations

26 recommendations for the broader NHS to enhance maternity and neonatal care across the system

Training and Supervision

Improve training and supervision for midwives and medical staff

Teamwork and Communication

Enhance teamwork and communication among healthcare professionals

Reporting and Learning

Establish robust systems for reporting and learning from incidents

Regulatory Oversight

Strengthen regulatory oversight to ensure patient safety

Transparency and Accountability

Increase transparency and accountability within the NHS

Culture of Compassion

Promote a culture of compassion, care, and professionalism


Podcasts by Inquests and Inquiries

Podcasts by other providers

Downloadable files

Resource

Web Address

Report of the Morecambe Bay Investigation - GOV.UK

Understanding the Kirkup Report - Royal College of Midwives

Maternity and neonatal services in East Kent: 'Reading the Signals' report - GOV.UK


Links to other resources

Select videos

A full playlist gallery is at the bottom of the page.

Image Gallery

Video Gallery

The player below has a loaded playlist of videos related to this topic. Clicking on the fast forward/skip bottom will take you to the next video.

bottom of page