top of page
< Back

Death of Surjit Singh Chhokar

The Chhokar inquiry consisted of two non-statutory reviews that investigated the systemic failures and institutional racism following the 1998 murder of Surjit Singh Chhokar in Scotland. These reports heavily criticized the police and prosecution for mishandling the case and failing to support the family, leading to over 100 recommendations for structural reform. Ultimately, the inquiry’s legacy triggered the 2011 Double Jeopardy Act, which enabled a successful retrial and the final conviction of Ronnie Coulter in 2016.

The Background (1998–2000)

Surjit Singh Chhokar, a 32-year-old waiter, was stabbed to death outside his home in Overtown, North Lanarkshire, in November 1998. Three men—Ronnie Coulter, Andrew Coulter, and David Montgomery—were arrested.

However, the prosecution made the controversial decision to try them in two separate trials:


  • 1999 Trial: Ronnie Coulter was tried alone. He was acquitted of murder (convicted only of assault), largely because he blamed the other two men.

  • 2000 Trial: Andrew Coulter and David Montgomery were tried together. They were also acquitted of murder after blaming Ronnie Coulter.


The Two Official Inquiries (2001)

Following a massive justice campaign led by the Chhokar family and their lawyer Aamer Anwar, the Scottish Government commissioned two independent reports, published in October 2001:


  1. The Jandoo Report: Led by Dr. Raj Jandoo, this inquiry focused on the police and the liaison with the family. It concluded that institutional racism existed within the police and the prosecution service, noting that the family had been treated with "sheer arrogance" and that the police failed to investigate a racial motive for the crime.


  2. The Campbell Report: Led by Sir Anthony Campbell, this inquiry looked at the Crown Office's decision-making. It criticized the decision to try the suspects separately, which effectively allowed them to point the finger at each other without a unified case to stop them.


The Chhokar family and their lawyer, Aamer Anwar, repeatedly campaigned for a full public statutory inquiry (similar to the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry in England), but the Scottish Executive (now the Scottish Government) chose instead to commission two independent, non-statutory "reviews."


Impact and Ultimate Justice

The inquiries led to massive reforms in the Scottish legal system, including:


  • The creation of an Inspectorate of Prosecution to ensure accountability.

  • Changes to the "Double Jeopardy" law in 2011, which previously prevented someone from being tried twice for the same crime.


Because of the change in law, the case was reopened. In 2016, eighteen years after the murder, Ronnie Coulter was finally convicted of the murder in a new trial and sentenced to life in prison.


Key Takeaway

The Chhokar inquiry is a landmark in British legal history because it forced the Scottish justice system to confront its own biases and procedural failures, eventually leading to one of the most significant successful "double jeopardy" retrials in the UK.

Key numbers at a glance

​

Recommendations

​

Months to complete

​

Cost in millions      (if known)

1

Deaths (direct)

Recommendations

Key recommendations from the two inquiries:


1. Tackling Institutional Racism (Jandoo Report)

The most profound finding was that the police and the Crown Office were "institutionally racist." The recommendations aimed to fix this by:

  • Mandatory Training: Implementing comprehensive race awareness and diversity training for all police officers and staff within the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).

  • Recruitment: Setting targets to increase the representation of ethnic minorities within the Scottish legal and police systems.

  • Defining Racial Incidents: Adopting the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry definition of a racial incident: "any incident which is perceived to be racist by the victim or any other person."

  • Victim Support: Establishing specialized units to support bereaved families from ethnic minority backgrounds, ensuring they are treated with dignity rather than "arrogance or suspicion."

2. Legal and Prosecution Reforms (Campbell Report)

The inquiry heavily criticized the decision to try the three suspects in two separate trials, which allowed them to blame each other.

  • Joinder of Accused: A recommendation that where multiple people are suspected of a single murder, every effort must be made to try them together in a single trial to prevent "cut-throat" defences from causing a miscarriage of justice.

  • Creation of the Inspectorate: The establishment of the Inspectorate of Prosecution in Scotland. This created an independent body to oversee the Crown Office and ensure their decision-making was transparent and competent.

  • Case Management: Improving the handover process between the police and prosecutors to ensure all evidence (especially regarding racial motives) is clearly communicated.

3. Family Liaison and Communication

The Chhokar family was famously left in the dark during the initial trials. The inquiry recommended:

  • Interpretation Services: Ensuring that high-quality, professional interpreters are available for all family meetings and legal proceedings.

  • Information Rights: Giving victims and their families a formal right to be kept informed of key decisions, such as why certain charges were dropped or why a trial was being split.

  • Liaison Officers: The formalization of the Family Liaison Officer (FLO) role within Scottish police forces to act as a dedicated link between the investigation and the family.

4. The Long-Term Legislative Change (Double Jeopardy)

While not an immediate recommendation of the 2001 reports, the inquiries highlighted a "loophole" that eventually led to the Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Act 2011.

  • This allowed for the retrial of individuals if "new and compelling evidence" came to light or if the original trial was tainted. This was the specific recommendation/reform that allowed Ronnie Coulter to be re-indicted and finally convicted in 2016.

Podcasts by Inquests and Inquiries

Podcasts by other providers

Downloadable files


Links to other resources

Official

  1. HMA v Ronnie Coulter

  2. Chhokar Inquiries: 7 Nov 2001: Scottish Parliament debates - TheyWorkForYou

  3. Copy of Jandoo report (in Sheku site)

  4. Meeting of the Parliament: 24/10/2001 | Scottish Parliament Website

  5. [ARCHIVED CONTENT] The Report of an Inquiry into Crown (Campbell report)

  6. [ARCHIVED CONTENT] REPORT OF THE INQUIRY INTO THE LIAISON ARRANGEMENTS BETWEEN THE POLICE, THE PROCURATOR FISCAL SERVICE AND THE CROWN OFFICE AND THE FAMILY OF THE DECEASED SURJIT SINGH CHHOKAR IN CONNECTION WITH THE MURDER OF SURJIT SINGH CHHOKAR AND THE RELATED PROSECUTIONS


News and context

  1. "Race claims in Chhokar murder". BBC News. 28 November 2000.

  2. BBC Staff (5 October 2016). "Ronnie Coulter convicted of 1998 Chhokar murder after second trial". BBC News.

  3. Seenan, Gerard (8 December 2000). "Stabbing that exposed Scots racism". The Guardian.

  4. Burrell, Ian (18 March 1999). "Sikh killing echo of Lawrence case". The Independent. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022.

  5. "Race claims in Chhokar murder". BBC News. 28 November 2000.

  6. Burell, Ian (23 March 1999). "Lawrence father backs campaign". The Independent. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022.

  7. "Chhokar trial pair sent to jail". BBC News. 8 February 2001.

  8. "Chhokar: Jandoo report at a glance". 24 October 2001.

  9. Seenan, Gerard (25 October 2001). "Scottish justice racist, murder case review finds". The Guardian.

  10. "Chhokar murder: Lord Advocate orders new probe into 1998 killing". BBC News. 26 January 2012.

  11. "Ronnie Coulter appears in court over Surjit Singh Chhokar death". BBC News. 25 March 2015.

  12. Brooks, Libby (5 October 2016). "Man found guilty of murdering Surjit Singh Chhokar after retrial". The Guardian. London.

  13. "Surjit Singh Chhokar killer Ronnie Coulter to appeal life sentence". The Herald. 14 November 2016.

  14. Family devastated by reports | The Herald

Select videos

Some useful videos  (if available)

Video slider

Useful playlist (if available)

bottom of page