top of page
< Back

Bristol Royal Infirmary

The inquiry investigated the management of children's heart surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary, identifying failures and making recommendations to improve patient safety.

The Bristol Royal Infirmary Inquiry chaired by Professor Sir Ian Kennedy, was a comprehensive public investigation into the management of children's heart surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary between 1984 and 1995. The inquiry was initiated in response to concerns about the high mortality rates and substandard care provided to pediatric cardiac patients during this period. The inquiry commenced in October 1998 and concluded with the publication of its final report in July 2001, spanning a total of 36 months and costing approximately £13 million.


The inquiry's primary objective was to uncover the reasons behind the elevated mortality rates and to identify systemic failures within the hospital's management and clinical practices. The investigation revealed a series of significant shortcomings in the hospital's approach to pediatric cardiac care. One of the most critical findings was the lack of adequate training and experience among the surgical staff, which directly contributed to the poor outcomes for the patients. The inquiry also highlighted issues related to the hospital's organizational structure, including ineffective communication and collaboration between different departments and medical professionals.


Furthermore, the inquiry identified a culture of complacency and resistance to change within the hospital, which hindered efforts to address the problems and improve patient care. This culture was exacerbated by the failure of senior management to recognize and act upon early warning signs and concerns raised by both staff and external bodies. The report also pointed out that the existing regulatory and oversight mechanisms were insufficient to detect and rectify the issues at an earlier stage.


As a result of the inquiry, a total of 198 recommendations were made to improve patient safety and the overall quality of care in the NHS. These recommendations encompassed various aspects of healthcare delivery, including the establishment of a robust system for monitoring and reporting clinical performance, the implementation of mandatory training and accreditation for specialist surgeons, and the development of clear guidelines for clinical governance and accountability.


The inquiry's findings and recommendations have had a profound impact on the NHS, leading to significant reforms aimed at enhancing patient safety and ensuring that similar incidents do not occur in the future. The establishment of the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) and the Commission for Health Improvement (CHI) were direct outcomes of the inquiry, reflecting the commitment to improving standards of care and fostering a culture of continuous learning and improvement within the healthcare system.


In one sentence: The Bristol Royal Infirmary Inquiry investigated the management of children's heart surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary, leading to 198 recommendations aimed at improving patient safety and healthcare quality in the NHS.


Key numbers at a glance

198

Recommendations

36

Months to complete

13

Cost in millions      (if known)

35

Deaths (direct)

Recommendations


Recommendation

Details

Training and Accreditation

Implement mandatory training and accreditation for specialist surgeons.

Clinical Governance

Develop clear guidelines for clinical governance and accountability.

Monitoring and Reporting

Establish a robust system for monitoring and reporting clinical performance.

Communication and Collaboration

Improve communication and collaboration between departments and medical professionals.

Regulatory Oversight

Strengthen regulatory and oversight mechanisms to detect and rectify issues early.

Culture of Improvement

Foster a culture of continuous learning and improvement within the healthcare system.


Podcasts by Inquests and Inquiries

Podcasts by other providers



Downloadable files

Links to other resources

Select videos

A full playlist gallery is at the bottom of the page.






Image Gallery

Video Gallery

The player below has a loaded playlist of videos related to this topic. Clicking on the fast forward/skip bottom will take you to the next video.

bottom of page